Imagine your company pays KShs. 100 million for sixteen parcels of prime agricultural land. Your advocates confirm that the seller, a well-known co-operative union, is the registered proprietor. The titles are transferred into your name and you take possession. A decade later, a court cancels every one of those titles and orders you off the land. You did nothing dishonest. Can that really happen?
On 13th November 2026, the Court of Appeal at Nyeri (S. ole Kantai, Mumbi Ngugi and Katwa Kigen, JJ.A.) answered with a resounding yes in Fikah Acres Limited v Robert Kinuthia Mungai, Kenya Planters Co-operative Union Ltd (In Liquidation) & the Chief Land Registrar (Civil Appeal No. E218 of 2024) [2026] KECA 2586 (KLR).
The Court dismissed the purchaser’s appeal with costs and affirmed the cancellation of its titles. In doing so, it consolidated the modern Kenyan law on root of title, the bona fide purchaser defence, Land Control Board consent, expert evidence and the limits of section 99 of the Land Act.
Every buyer, lender, developer and conveyancer in Kenya should take note.
The Story Behind the Dispute
In 1972, Robert Kinuthia Mungai bought LR No. 1363/2, a farm of about 1,238 acres. In 1984 he charged it to the Kenya Planters Co-operative Union (KPCU) to secure financing, and in 1986 KPCU took over management of his coffee farm. When repayment disputes arose, the parties signed an Agreement dated 23rd November 1998 under which part of his undeveloped land would be transferred to KPCU in settlement of a debt said to be KSh 48 million.
The Agreement was conditional. A valuation by Tysons Limited and a survey by Thiga Survey Consortium had to be done first, to work out the acreage equal to the debt. Neither was ever carried out. Mr. Mungai rescinded the Agreement by letter dated 13th July 2009 and refused in writing to sign any assignments.
Even so, Indentures of Assignment dated 7th August 2014 transferred the suit parcels to KPCU, which promptly sold them to Fikah Acres Limited. About 860 acres changed hands while litigation over the land was still pending and status quo orders were in force. Mr. Mungai alleged forgery. The Environment and Land Court at Murang’a (L. N. Gacheru, J.) agreed and, on 7th November 2024, cancelled the titles, granted eviction and declaratory orders, declined mesne profits and awarded costs. Fikah Acres appealed, represented by Paul Muite SC, with KPCU (In Liquidation) supporting the appeal.
Land Title Due Diligence: The locus Principles Established by the Court of Appeal
Part 1: A Title Is Only as Good as Its Root
The Court reaffirmed Munyu Maina v Hiram Gathiha Maina [2013] eKLR: “when a registered proprietor’s root of title is under challenge, it is not sufficient to dangle the instrument of title as proof of ownership. The registered proprietor must go beyond the instrument and demonstrate the legality of how he acquired the title.” Once Mr. Mungai challenged the assignments, “the burden shifted to the 2nd respondent to explain the complete chain leading to the acquisition of title. That burden was not discharged.”
The defects were many. There was no valuation, no survey, no Land Control Board consent, no proof of stamp duty, no identity card or KRA PIN details for the transferor, and the attestation by the transferor’s advocate was undated and disputed. The forensic document examiner found that the signatures were not Mr. Mungai’s, and the Land Registrar’s own records corroborated that finding.
Part 2: Conditions Precedent Are Not Optional
The appellant said the trial court had rewritten the 1998 Agreement. The Court disagreed: “The trial Judge did not rewrite the agreement. Rather, she found that the conditions precedent stipulated therein had not been demonstrated to have been fulfilled.” Since the Agreement set out a mechanism for fixing the acreage rather than the acreage itself, it “could not, by itself, justify the transfer of the disputed parcels in the absence of compliance with the very conditions the parties deliberately incorporated into it.” The Court also agreed that Mr. Mungai “may not have got fair value for his land.”
Part 3: No Land Control Board Consent, No Transaction
Under section 6(1) of the Land Control Act, controlled transactions in agricultural land are “void for all purposes” without consent. The Court held that such consent is “not a procedural formality but a substantive statutory requirement going to the very validity of the transactions.” It distinguished Willy Kimutai Kitilit v Michael Kibet [2018] eKLR. Equity may soften the Act where the factual foundation of a bargain is established, but it cannot rescue a transaction attended by alleged forgery and an unproven root. Invoking the ex turpi causa maxim, the Court warned that a court “cannot ignore the legislative command or enforce rights purportedly arising from such transactions.”
Part 4: The Bona Fide Purchaser Defence Now Starts With the Vendor’s Title
This is the heart of the judgment. Drawing on Samuel Kamere v Lands Registrar, Kajiado [2015] eKLR, Dina Management Ltd v County Government of Mombasa [2023] KESC 30 (KLR) and Sehmi & Another v Tarabana Company Ltd [2025] KESC 21 (KLR), the Court held that “the current jurisprudential position requires a sequential inquiry:
First, whether the root title is lawful and capable of transmission; secondly, whether the purchaser satisfies the traditional attributes of a bona fide purchaser.” Innocence and payment are no longer enough. The purchaser must prove “that the vendor has a lawful title.”
Fikah Acres failed both stages. Its director joined the company after the deal and gave hearsay evidence. The advocate who handled the purchase swore an affidavit but was not called. The same advocate acted for buyer and seller. There were pending suits, status quo orders and lis pendens on the record. On these facts, “all the questions around the propriety of the title[s] and transfer were on the face of the appellant.”
Applying nemo dat quod non habet, the Court held that the vendor “could not convey to the appellant a better title than it lawfully possessed… irrespective of the latter’s assertions regarding consideration, good faith or subsequent registration.” To hold otherwise “would be to permit an unlawful root of title to mature into a lawful one through a succession of transactions.”
Part 5: Section 99 of the Land Act Protects Auction Buyers, Not Private Settlements
The appellant relied on section 99 of the Land Act, which limits a chargor’s remedy to damages where a statutory power of sale is irregularly exercised. The Court held the reliance “misplaced” because the sale was made “pursuant to the agreement dated 23rd November, 1998. The two are not the same thing.” A statutory sale would have required valuation, notices, publication and the sale of the originally charged parcel, not later uncharged subdivisions. In any event, section 99 “does not sanitise fraud or validate a title whose root remains unproved.”
The appeal was dismissed with costs to Mr. Mungai, and the refusal of mesne profits, which had not been specifically proved, was upheld.
PRACTICAL IMPLICATIONS
- Look behind the register. A clean official search is the start of due diligence, not the end. Trace the vendor’s complete chain of title and obtain the instruments, consents and receipts at every link.
- Demand the documents that make a transfer lawful: Land Control Board consent for agricultural land, proof of stamp duty, and the transferor’s identity and KRA PIN particulars. Their absence from the registry file is a red flag the Court expects buyers to see.
- Search the courts as well as the registry. Pending suits, status quo orders and lis pendens bind purchasers. A buyer who ignores them will not be treated as innocent.
- Keep witnesses who can actually prove due diligence. A director who joined later gives hearsay. Call the advocate or officer who did the work.
- Debt settlements by transfer of land are not statutory sales. Lenders taking land in satisfaction of debt cannot shelter behind section 99 of the Land Act and must satisfy every condition precedent, valuation and consent in the settlement agreement.
- Challenge adverse expert evidence at trial. An unchallenged forensic report that the registry records corroborate will almost certainly be decisive on appeal.
- Purchasers who lose their titles should look to their vendor. Where the vendor is in liquidation, as KPCU was, that recovery may be worth little, so contractual warranties, indemnities, escrow arrangements and title insurance matter.
The decision will be remembered for the KSh 100 million purchase it could not save. Its lasting value lies in the discipline it imposes: in Kenyan land law, the register tells you who holds title, but only the root tells you whether that title is worth having.
This article is provided free of charge for information purposes only; it does not constitute legal advice and should not be relied on as such. No responsibility for the accuracy and/or correctness of the information and commentary as set out in the article should be held without seeking specific legal advice on the subject matter. If you have any query regarding the same, please do not hesitate to contact the Litigation Department at Wamae & Allen LLP: Litigation@wamaeallen.com.







